There is the natural consequence in which the discipline naturally occurs as a result of the childs behavior i. There are many statistics on spanking such as mothers spank more than fathers, rural families spank more than urban families, a surprising Catholics spank less than Protestants, older woman spank more than younger women, etc.
In the context of causing pain in order to punish, it is distinct from physically restraining a child to protect the child or another person from harm.
For instance, a tree year old child who runs in the road will learn quicker from a butt smack than receiving a prize for remaining on the sidewalk. Corporal punishment may not be effective in some cases, but when carried out properly there may be positive change.
Interviews with parents also revealed a sharp decline in more severe forms of punishment, such as punching or the use of objects to hit children, which are likely to cause injury. There are many statistics on spanking such as mothers spank more than fathers, rural families spank more than urban families, a surprising Catholics spank less than Protestants, older woman spank more than younger women, etc.
As previously stated, there are always two sides to every debate. It has been proven in studies that children who receive corporal punishment as a form of discipline face many challenges. There is also the belief that corporal punishment is better than discipline which utilizes isolation and that spanking is really only effective depending in the childs age Niolon, The Vatican commission appointed to advise the Pope on sexual abuse within the church criticized the Pope for his statement, contending that physical punishments and the infliction of pain were inappropriate methods for disciplining children.
The church rejects all outside interferences from the state regarding this matter. It is up to the individual states to create legislation in reference to corporal punishment.
As a result of her research and documented in her writings, Cope states, The goal of discipline, whatever the method, is to set reasonable limits that protect children from harm and teach them what is safe, right, and acceptable. All this should be done when absolutely necessary and in moderation so as not to cause detriment to the childs development.
Another concern is that corporal punishment may be a means for parents to release or vent out their feelings rather than explaining or teaching proper behavior or correcting a wrong that the child has committed.
As a result, it is difficult to make an exact conclusion on the effects of corporal punishment and then place it in the category of abuse. The church believes it to be the right and responsibility of parents to train and discipline their children in accordance with the Holy Scriptures Proverbs At this time, only 31 states have banned corporal punishment in the schools while all 50 states still allow it to be used in the home in a reasonable manner.
My boys are older now but I do remember how I disciplined them when necessary. Joan Durrant and Ron Ensom write that "Together, results consistently suggest that physical punishment has a direct causal effect on externalizing behavior, whether through a reflexive response to pain, modeling, or coercive family processes".
Many researchers believe that corporal punishment leads to children eventually becoming adult abusers. Law And Contemporary Problems, 73 2 According to Durrant, data from various official sources in Sweden show that these goals are being met.
Once again, this can easily turn into more of abuse than discipline which raises questions about laws concerning corporal punishment. Many European countries have banned corporal punishment in the schools and in the home.
If it is decided to use corporal punishment as a discipline method for a child you must be willing to accept the end result for your actions according to any laws. The case against spanking.
There is also the belief that corporal punishment is better than discipline which utilizes isolation and that spanking is really only effective depending in the childs age Niolon, He is a really good listener and since he only had girls and I was the oldest, I often had the chores helping him the boys would normally have done chopping fire wood, fixing fences, laying concrete, mowing the lawn, etc.
Your laughter metamorphosed into howls in the first stanza shows On the other hand, students receiving non physical forms of punishment, such as time out or restriction, behaved much better Cope, However, it must be noted that a child who receives a couple of spankings will more than likely not cause them to become bullies, thieves or repeat criminals.
What exactly is corporal punishment A simple definition of corporal punishment would be the utilization of physical force to cause pain as a means of discipline without causing injury in order to correct or control the recipient Jones, It has also been debated that some form of corporal punishment is acceptable.
The use of corporal punishment also causes children to develop antisocial behavior which can cause lower self-esteem, alcohol and substance abuse, and depression. That opinion can be based on the ideology of society and the changes over the years about how to discipline children.
Alternatives to Physical Punishment. Keep in mind that if corporal punishment is administered correctly, spankings and not beatings, it may have a more positive outcome in that the child will understand why they are being punished, and will not feel that they are being abused or just used as an aggression tool.
Explanation For those who contend that students straighten This book outlines seven habits that are pretty well established as effective techniques in running a family full of kids that are considerate, self monitoring and respectful while also being critical thinkers.
They urge support for parents to use "more effective, non-violent methods of discipline". For instance, a tree year old child who runs in the road will learn quicker from a butt smack than receiving a prize for remaining on the sidewalk.Corporal Punishment in Schools Corporal punishment is the deliberate infliction of pain as retribution for an offence, or for the purpose of disciplining or reforming a wrongdoer, or to deter attitudes or behaviour deemed unacceptable (Miller.
I think that corporal punishment in schools is a necessary method of discipline. I think that corporal punishment in schools is a necessary method of discipline.
WASHINGTON — Corporal punishment remains a widely used discipline technique in most American families, but it has also been a subject of controversy within the child development and psychological communities.
In a large-scale meta-analysis of 88 studies, psychologist Elizabeth Thompson Gershoff. ntroduction to PsychologyInstructor Stephanie Anderson September 8, Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Is corporal punishment considered to be an effective form of discipline for children We have all been privy to occurrences of corporal punishment to discipline children a mother smacking her child to control a.
Is punishment necessary? Ask Question. Disclaimer: I assume you mean "punishment" not as in "corporal punishment" (which is, as torbengb pointed out, illegal in many countries) Punishment and Discipline is absolutely necesary for a child to grow up healthy and well balanced.
The type of punishment, however, varies greatly. Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Essay Sample. ntroduction to PsychologyInstructor Stephanie Anderson September 8, Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Is corporal punishment considered to be an effective form of discipline for children We have all been privy to occurrences of corporal punishment to discipline .Download